The Role of Governance in Sustainable Education Transformation

by Grace Hu

“一个肮脏的国家，如果人人讲规则而不是空谈道德，最终会变成一个有人味儿的正常国家，道德自然会逐渐回归；反之，一个干净的国家，如果人人都不讲规则却大谈道德、谈高尚，天天没事儿就谈道德规范，人人大公无私，最终这个国家会堕落成为一个伪君子遍布的肮脏国家。”——胡适的《介绍我自己的思想》

In the realm of international education, the rhetoric of sustainability and ESG often prevails. However, despite the resonance of these principles, the translation into meaningful action remains a challenge. While many institutions voice their commitment to sustainability, the reality often sees initiatives used more for compliance than genuine transformation. This disconnect between intention and action highlights a critical necessity: a solid governance framework devoted to authentic sustainable practices.

Identifying the Disconnect:

The chasm between acknowledging the importance of sustainability and integrating these principles into educational institutions is glaringly evident. Studies reveal that while 90% of educational leaders express a commitment to sustainability, only 25% have policies or strategies in place to actualise these intentions (Source: Green Schools National Network). This stark contrast exemplifies a concerning trend where intentions falter when translated into actionable plans.

Moreover, a survey conducted by the International Baccalaureate Organisation reported that although 96% of participating schools expressed a commitment to sustainable development, only 32% had a dedicated governance structure specifically targeting sustainability within their institution. This disconnection showcases the gap between voiced commitments and operational implementation, emphasising the need for stronger governance in realising authentic sustainability goals.

Governance as a Catalyst for Sustainable Change:

A robust governance structure plays a pivotal role in steering genuine sustainability practices within international schools. Beyond paperwork and superficial compliance, effective governance models infuse sustainability into the institution’s core functions. This includes aligning sustainability with mission statements, strategic planning, operational policies, curriculum development, and daily practices.

Effective Governance Models:

Examining successful governance models becomes imperative to illustrate the tangible impact of sustainability initiatives. Case studies showcasing institutions that have embraced comprehensive governance structures offer valuable insights. Data from such models underscore how embedding sustainability into governance yields substantial benefits, not merely in compliance but in nurturing a sustainable culture. Here are some examples with different focus areas on Governance structure.

Mission and Vision Integration:

An effective governance framework incorporates sustainability into the core mission and vision of an educational institution. For instance, consider the Copenhagen International School. They revamped their mission to emphasise sustainable citizenship and integrated this philosophy into their strategic plan. This involved setting clear objectives, allocating resources, and appointing a dedicated sustainability committee, thereby creating a cohesive strategy that permeates all facets of the school’s operations.

Dedicated Governance Structures:

Schools like the United World Colleges have appointed Sustainability Task Forces or Advisory Boards comprising diverse stakeholders. These bodies oversee the integration of sustainable practices, ensuring alignment with educational objectives. Such structures empower decision-makers to oversee and drive sustainable initiatives systematically.

Policy Development and Implementation: 

Robust governance establishes clear policies and frameworks governing sustainability practices. Take the example of The International School of Brussels, which developed a comprehensive sustainability policy outlining objectives, strategies, and accountability measures. This policy drove tangible changes in waste reduction, energy efficiency, and curriculum redesign to embed sustainability across the school’s fabric.

Monitoring and Reporting Mechanisms: 

Implementing regular sustainability audits and reporting mechanisms is integral. Singapore American School, for instance, conducts annual sustainability assessments to gauge progress, identify areas for improvement, and transparently communicate their efforts to stakeholders. This practice fosters accountability and transparency within the institution.

Engagement and Community Involvement:

Governance extends to engaging stakeholders and fostering a culture of sustainability. Schools like UWCSEA involve students, staff, and parents through various initiatives, fostering a sense of ownership and commitment to sustainability efforts. Such engagement strategies create a collective responsibility toward sustainable practices.

Steps Toward a Sustainable Governance Framework

Turning intent into action demands a proactive approach. Educational leaders can implement various strategies to fortify governance frameworks for sustainability. Establishing dedicated committees, incorporating sustainability metrics into key performance indicators, integrating sustainability considerations into decision-making processes, and nurturing a pervasive culture of sustainability are among the actionable steps. But here are some tricky points.

Crafting a robust sustainability framework for educational institutions requires a neutral, objective perspective to foster comprehensive and effective change. While school leaders and internal stakeholders possess profound passion and expertise in education, their proximity to various vested interests within the institution can inadvertently influence the sustainability plan’s direction. In contrast, external sustainability partners offer an invaluable advantage. Their neutral standpoint ensures an impartial assessment, unclouded by internal biases, fostering a strategy that aligns with global best practices.

For instance, while internal teams might prioritise institutional goals over global sustainability benchmarks, external experts adeptly balance both, considering broader stakeholder interests. Moreover, these partners bring an extensive wealth of experience in navigating sustainability transitions across diverse sectors, leveraging their expertise to tailor strategies that align with educational objectives and global sustainability standards. This neutrality, combined with their experience, enriches the sustainability plan’s quality, rendering it adaptive, impactful, and harmonious with broader sustainability agendas.

Numerous instances across various sectors demonstrate the significance of neutral external perspectives in developing sustainable frameworks. In corporate governance, for instance, external auditors play a crucial role. Their impartial review ensures financial transparency and compliance, preventing internal biases from influencing financial reporting. Similarly, in international policy-making bodies or think tanks, independent advisors contribute a balanced view, free from partisan inclinations, to shape policies aligned with global interests.

In educational settings, although there might not be direct statistics available, the principle holds true. External consultants, especially those specialising in sustainability, contribute impartial evaluations and strategies, enabling institutions to integrate global best practices without being encumbered by internal biases or limitations. This approach ensures a broader view of sustainability, encompassing both local educational objectives and global sustainability imperatives.

Moreover, a fundamental commitment within the organisation is indispensable before engaging external experts or partners. Leadership commitment, annual strategies, and the integration of a specific role for sustainability within the organizational structure are pivotal. This internal role, such as a Chief Sustainability Officer (CSO) or sustainability leader, signifies a serious dedication to sustainability goals. The advantages of having an internal sustainability leader are multifaceted. Firstly, it guarantees dedicated commitment, ensuring a consistent focus on long-term sustainability objectives. Secondly, it allows for a deeper embedding of sustainability principles into the organisation’s culture and policies. Thirdly, an internal role offers an in-depth understanding of the organisation’s unique challenges, allowing tailored sustainability strategies. Fourthly, it facilitates real-time monitoring and adaptation of strategies, staying ahead of emerging trends. Additionally, this internal role promotes team collaboration, a crucial aspect emphasised by the UNSDGs, ensuring that no one is left behind in sustainability endeavours. It fosters cost-efficiency by streamlining sustainability initiatives and contributes significantly to the organisation’s reputation and brand image.

In essence, the cornerstone of a robust sustainability strategy lies in internal commitment and a dedicated role within the organisation. This internal backbone provides the foundation for a sustainable governance framework. External expertise and partnerships further fortify this structure, culminating in a comprehensive and impactful sustainability plan.

Beyond compliance, the transformational potential of sustainable governance cannot be overstated. Institutions often view sustainability as an isolated endeavour, resulting in missed opportunities for holistic integration. Shifting the paradigm from “I want to do it” to “I am committed to it” is pivotal. This commitment requires a governance structure that fosters accountability, transparency, and genuine action. Embedding sustainability into the very fabric of an organisation rather than treating it as an add-on is essential for meaningful, lasting impact.

Ask yourself, how is sustainability reflected in the supply chain? Do we have employee engagement? Do we discuss sustainability KPIs at the board level each time? Does every teacher think of sustainability in their “product” development, which is a lesson? How’s our financial strategy? Do we have to invest in green technologies, adopt clean energy sources or transparent reporting? As international school leaders, we need to think bigger, and broader with more vision, since we are watched and learned by the next generation every single second. Students and employees are learning together then that’s what you can “teach” our next generation first.

At its core, sustainable governance represents more than an aspiration or an addition to existing frameworks. It is the bedrock upon which resilient, forward-thinking institutions are built. Embracing sustainable governance goes beyond a checkbox exercise or a token acknowledgement; it’s about instilling an unwavering commitment to weaving sustainability into the very fabric of an institution’s existence. By championing a governance structure deeply rooted in sustainability, organisations harness the power to influence positive change, driving towards a future where sustainability isn’t just a choice but an irrefutable necessity for global progress and lasting impact.

Concluding with an emphasis on the urgency of translating intent into action through robust governance, I want to call for a paradigm shift. It urges leaders to break free from superficial initiatives and adopt a comprehensive approach to embed sustainability within the institutional DNA.

In unity for a sustainable future!

Grace Hu is the Global Head of International School Sustainability at Leading Your International School.

Book a free 30-minute consultancy call with Grace and get your International School’s sustainability strategy started.

To connect with Grace on WeChat, scan here: